So you’ve decided you need help to deal with the day-to-day tasks in your business that keep you up at night.
Naturally, you’re thinking about hiring a virtual executive assistant (EA). Which is OK, I guess, if you literally just need some straightforward admin help.
But lots of people make the mistake of hiring for specific tasks rather than for critical thinking skills. They’re looking for someone to help execute their to-do list, when what they actually need is someone to help them get to the bottom of why their to-do list is overwhelming in the first place.
In those cases, they probably don’t need an EA. They need a chief of staff (CoS).
Most people don’t know the difference. They think ‘EA’ and ‘CoS’ are just different titles for the same role at different levels. They’re not. And hiring the wrong role means you’ll still be overwhelmed, just with better-organised chaos.
An EA executes tasks with some autonomy and quick thinking. But, according to McKinsey, a CoS balances strategy and execution, managing operations, coordinating projects, solving problems, and thinking two steps ahead.
If you’re a founder, executive, or entrepreneur dealing with operational complexity, you don’t just need someone to manage your calendar. You also need someone to manage what needs to be managed while you focus on strategy.
Let me show you the difference, and why it matters more than you think.
The problem solver vs the problem seeker (or the difference between a chief of staff vs an executive assistant’s approach)
Most EAs are problem solvers and excel at completing tasks efficiently when you ask.
You need your calendar managed? Done.
Travel booked? Sorted.
Expenses processed? No problem.
And this is valuable, but it rarely solves the underlying problems. Because maybe your calendar is chaotic because you don’t have clear priorities, you haven’t set boundaries, and you’re in constant reactive mode.
A problem solver will organise your chaos. But a problem seeker will ask: “Why is there chaos in the first place?”
Here’s what that looks like in practice:
Problem Solver:
- You: “I need help with my calendar”
- EA: “Great! I’ll manage your calendar”
- Result: Your calendar is organised, but you’re still overwhelmed because the underlying issues (unclear priorities, poor boundaries, reactive scheduling) haven’t been addressed
Problem Seeker:
- You: “I need help with my calendar”
- CoS: “Tell me more about what’s not working. What does a typical week look like?”
- You: “I’m constantly double-booked, I miss important calls, I have no time for deep work…”
- CoS: “It sounds like calendar chaos is just the symptom. The real issue is that you don’t have protected time for strategic thinking, and you’re reacting to everything instead of being proactive. Let’s look at the bigger picture – what’s actually important to you, what can you eliminate or delegate, and how can we redesign your time so the urgent doesn’t take priority over the important?”
- Result: Your calendar gets organised, but more importantly, the way you spend your time fundamentally changes
See the difference?
One approach makes you 10% more efficient. The other approach changes how you work.
Why this matters more than you think
When you hire a problem solver, you get tactical support. Tasks get done and things run smoothly(ish).
But you’re still drowning. You’re still overwhelmed. You’re still working 60-hour weeks and feeling like you’re not making progress on what actually matters.
Why? Because you’re solving the wrong problems.
Your calendar isn’t the problem, but it’s revealing deeper issues:
- Unclear priorities (you’re saying yes to everything because you haven’t defined what matters most)
- Poor boundaries (urgent always trumps important because you don’t protect strategic time)
- Reactive mode (you’re responding to what’s in front of you instead of proactively managing your time)
- Hidden inefficiencies (you’re doing things that could be systematised, delegated, or eliminated)
A problem solver will help you manage these symptoms more efficiently.
A problem seeker will help you identify and solve the root causes.
That’s the difference between hiring an EA and hiring a strategic partner.
What to look for in a remote chief of staff
Now that you understand the chief of staff vs executive assistant difference, here’s what to actually look for when hiring a virtual chief of staff:
1. Strategic thinking (not just task execution)
Red flag: They ask, “What do you need me to do?”
Green flag: They ask, “What’s not working right now? What’s draining your energy? What keeps falling through the cracks?”
A strategic CoS doesn’t wait for a task list. They observe, identify patterns, and proactively address issues before you even realise they’re problems.
Questions to ask:
- “Tell me about a time you identified a problem your client didn’t realise they had”
- “How do you approach a new client relationship? What’s your process for understanding their needs?”
If they can’t answer these thoughtfully, they’re a problem solver, not a problem seeker.
2. Anticipation (not just reaction)
Red flag: They wait for you to tell them what needs doing
Green flag: They see what’s coming and flag it before you have to ask
A great CoS is two steps ahead. As well as responding to your requests, they’re anticipating what you’ll need next week, next month, next quarter.
Examples of anticipation:
- They notice you have a board meeting in 3 weeks and proactively start preparing materials
- They see a key relationship hasn’t been touched in 2 months and suggest getting in touch
- They identify a recurring bottleneck in your workflow and propose a system to fix it
Questions to ask:
- “How do you stay ahead of your client’s needs?”
- “How do you balance proactive work with reactive requests?”
3. Systems thinking (not just task completion)
Red flag: They complete tasks one by one without seeing patterns
Green flag: They identify recurring issues and build systems to prevent them
A problem solver completes your to-do list. A problem seeker asks, “Why do these same tasks keep appearing on your to-do list? How can we systematise this so it doesn’t need your attention anymore?”
Examples of systems thinking:
- Instead of manually tracking expenses, they set up a system that captures and categorises them in real time
- Alongside reminding you about important dates, they build a relationship maintenance system that keeps key contacts warm without you having to remember
Questions to ask:
- “Tell me about a system you’ve built for a client”
- “How do you approach recurring tasks?”
- “What’s your philosophy on automation vs. manual work?”
4. Communication style (clear, proactive, async-friendly)
Red flag: They need constant check-ins and real-time communication
Green flag: They communicate clearly in writing, provide updates proactively, and work well asynchronously
If you’re hiring a remote CoS, you need someone who can work independently without constant supervision. That means clear, proactive communication and not waiting for you to ask for updates.
What good communication looks like:
- They send end-of-day or end-of-week summaries without being asked
- They flag issues early with proposed solutions (not just problems)
- They document decisions and actions so that nothing gets lost
- They’re comfortable with async communication (email, voice notes, project management tools)
Questions to ask:
- “How do you keep clients updated on progress?”
- “What’s your preferred communication style? How do you handle time zone differences?”
5. Holistic Thinking (business and personal)
Red flag: They only want to handle “business” tasks
Green flag: They understand that your personal life and professional life are interconnected
Here’s something most people don’t realise: the best CoS support you as a whole person, not just as a business owner.
Why? Because any personal chaos bleeds into your professional performance.
If you’re stressed about managing life admin/logistics, that’s taking up mental space that could be used for strategic thinking. A holistic CoS handles both – not because they’re a personal assistant, but because they understand that freeing up your mental space means addressing what’s actually draining your energy, whether that’s business or personal.
Questions to ask:
- “Do you support clients with personal logistics as well as business operations?”
- “How do you view the boundary between business and personal support?”
6. Experience in your industry (or adjacent)
Red flag: They have no understanding of your world
Green flag: They’ve worked with similar clients or in similar industries
You don’t need someone who’s done your exact job. But you do need someone who understands the context in which you’re operating.
If you’re a remote-first founder, you need a CoS who understands distributed teams, async communication, and startup dynamics.
If you’re in a regulated industry (finance, law, healthcare), you need a CoS who understands compliance, governance, and the importance of documentation.
If you’re a consultant, you need a CoS who understands client relationship management, proposal processes, and project-based work.
Questions to ask:
- “What types of clients have you worked with?”
- “What do you know about [my industry]?”
- “How do you get up to speed on a new client’s business?”
Red flags to avoid
Now that you know what to look for, here are the red flags that signal you’re about to hire the wrong person:
1. They can’t articulate their approach
If they can’t explain how they work, what their philosophy is, or how they add value beyond task execution, they’re probably a problem solver, not a problem seeker.
2. They focus only on tools and skills
“I’m proficient in Microsoft Office, Google Workspace, Asana, Slack…”
That’s fine, but tools are commodities. What matters is how they think.
3. They don’t ask questions about your business
If they’re not curious about what you do, what your challenges are, or what success looks like for you, they’re not going to be a strategic partner.
4. They promise unrealistic results
“I’ll save you 20 hours per week!” “I’ll double your productivity!”
Real strategic support doesn’t come with guarantees like this. It comes from understanding your specific situation and solving your specific problems.
5. They’re vague about past experience
If they can’t give concrete examples of how they’ve helped past clients, or if they’re reluctant to provide testimonials/references, that’s a red flag.
6. They don’t have clear boundaries
“I’m available 24/7!” “I can do anything you need!”
This sounds good in theory, but it’s actually a problem. A good CoS has boundaries. They know their strengths, their capacity, and they’re clear about what they can and can’t do.
7. Poor communication during the hiring process
If they’re slow to respond, unclear in their communication, or unprofessional during the hiring or onboarding process, that’s how they’ll be as your CoS.
Whether you’re searching for a remote chief of staff or a strategic executive assistant, the principles are the same: look for problem-seeking, strategic thinking, and holistic support – not just task execution.
The bottom line
Hiring virtual executive support is a significant investment, not just financially, but in terms of trust, access, and the time it takes to onboard someone into your world.
If you hire a problem solver, you’ll get tactical support. Tasks will get done. Things will run more smoothly.
But if you hire a problem seeker – or someone who helps you identify what’s actually draining your energy and mental space, then solves those root problems – you’ll fundamentally change how you work.
You’ll move from reactive to proactive. From overwhelmed to focused. From drowning in operations to doing your best work.
That’s the difference between hiring a VA and hiring a strategic partner.
So before you post that job description asking for “calendar management and travel booking,” ask yourself:
Do I need someone to execute my to-do list? Or do I need someone to help me figure out why I’m overwhelmed in the first place?
If it’s the latter, you’re looking for a problem seeker.
And that changes everything about how you hire.
Ready to explore strategic executive support? Click here to see how I work.
